Loading...
Logo



Giving Season Is Growth Season Rethinking Year-End Donor Acquisition

As November and December approach, giving ramps up, campaigns intensify and fundraisers focus on maximizing year-end revenue. But giving season is also growth season.

At our recent Fundraise FWD gathering, Carolina Bendaña from ST and Philip King from STella! – ST’s digital growth engine challenged us to look beyond the year-end “harvest” and see an opportunity to begin relationships that last. Here are my top 7 takeaways from their session:

➡️ Don’t just harvest. Plant.

Across the clients Philip examined, roughly 48% of online revenue arrived in November and December. His analysis also found that 28% of new-to-file acquisitions occurred in December, with another 8% in November.

Those aren’t simply year-end transactions. They’re new relationships. The question isn’t only “How much can we raise?” It’s “How many relationships can we begin, and what will we do with them?”

➡️ Acquisition isn’t about volume. It’s about the right volume.

As Carolina pointed out, doubling a direct mail acquisition campaign doesn’t automatically double the donors. Once your strongest lists are exhausted, expanding into weaker sources can increase your cost per donor.

Instead, ask which sources produce your strongest donors, what volume the available data supports and whether smaller, strategically timed campaigns could build familiarity before the holiday rush.

Growth doesn’t always mean mailing more. It means being smarter about whom you mail, when and why.

➡️ Stop measuring acquisition like a revenue campaign.

Return on ad spend makes sense when a campaign’s objective is immediate revenue. But acquisition needs a longer-term lens.

As Carolina argued, ask how many new donors you acquired, what they cost, whether they became monthly donors or made a second gift, and how their value develops over time.

We already invest substantially in channels such as face-to-face fundraising. Digital acquisition deserves the same patience. The goal isn’t inexpensive donations. It’s valuable donor relationships.

➡️ Your donor doesn’t think in channels.

A donor might receive direct mail, see an ad, search for your organization and give through your website. Which channel “got” the donation may be less useful than asking how they worked together.

Direct mail, digital advertising, your website and email should create a connected experience—not feel like separate campaigns. Align the message, audience strategy and donor journey. No channel has to do the entire job.

➡️ Leads are not donors.

An email address, phone number or postal address has value. But a database full of leads isn’t a growing donor file. Philip cautioned against impressive lead-generation numbers without understanding how those leads become donors.

Distinguish between lead acquisition (bringing potential supporters into your ecosystem), donor acquisition (securing a first gift) and reacquisition (reconnecting with lapsed donors).

That last group already knows you and has demonstrated a willingness to give. Before spending everything on finding strangers, explore the opportunity inside your database.

➡️ And once they give? Slow down.

Philip found that 95% of new year-end donors started with a one-time gift. Only one in five holiday donors had given again by summer; roughly one in four returned the following December.

If someone gives for the first time in December, should January bring another ask—or a thank-you, a demonstration of impact and a chance to learn about the organization they’ve supported?

Build the next experience around donor behaviour rather than treating everyone identically. A December donor may simply be a December donor. Sharing impact and nurturing the relationship early in the relationship may be more valuable than relentlessly asking throughout the year.

➡️ Growth season starts now.

Year-end growth includes the first-time donor, the lapsed supporter who reconnects, the one-time donor who could become monthly and the prospect who remembers you when they’re ready to give.

So, this giving season, absolutely harvest. But don’t forget to plant.

Your December campaign isn’t only building this year’s results. It may be building next year’s donor file, too.

If you want to learn more about how ST Fundraising can help you develop and execute a successful acquisition strategy, email me at LizA@STfundraising.com.